Brisbane Insurance Repair Guide

IS IT WORTH REPAIRING
OR IS IT A WRITE-OFF?

When damage is significant, insurers weigh up the cost of repair against the value of your boat or caravan. Understanding how that decision gets made can help you navigate the process with confidence.

Quick Answer

There's no fixed percentage rule for boats and caravans like there sometimes is for cars. Insurers generally assess repair cost against the vessel's value on a case-by-case basis.

Insurers compare the cost to repair against your boat or caravan's insured value
Boats and caravans are typically assessed case-by-case, not against a fixed percentage threshold
A genuine, qualified repair quote is an important part of this decision
You can request the salvage back in some cases if your insurer declares a write-off

If your boat or caravan is facing a significant repair, getting a proper assessment and quote early helps ensure the decision is based on accurate information.

How Insurers Generally Make This Decision

When damage is extensive, an insurer needs to decide whether repairing the vessel is the more sensible option compared to paying out its insured value and writing it off. This generally comes down to comparing the cost of a proper repair against what the boat or caravan is actually worth.

Unlike cars, which in many cases follow a more standardised percentage-based threshold in some jurisdictions, boats and caravans are typically assessed individually, taking into account the specific damage, the age and condition of the vessel, and the realistic cost of restoring it properly.

What a Proper Repair Can Restore

Loading Model

Auto-rotating — turn on to drag & zoom

Factors That Influence the Decision

The total cost of repair, including materials, labour and any specialist work required
Your boat or caravan's insured value, whether agreed value or market value depending on your policy
The extent and type of damage, particularly structural damage versus cosmetic damage
The age and overall condition of the vessel before the damage occurred
Availability of parts or materials needed for the repair
Whether the vessel can be made safe and seaworthy or roadworthy again

Agreed Value vs Market Value: Why It Matters Here

If your policy is based on agreed value, the amount you and your insurer agreed on at the start of the policy is generally what's used in this comparison, removing some of the uncertainty. If your policy is based on market value, the assessed value at the time of the claim is used instead, which can sometimes lead to disagreement if you feel the valuation is too low.

Knowing which type of cover you hold matters when this kind of decision comes up.

What Happens If It's Declared a Write-Off?

If your insurer determines the cost of repair isn't justified against the vessel's value, they'll generally pay out the insured value (less any deductible) and the vessel becomes the insurer's property, often referred to as salvage.

In some cases, you may be able to request to keep the vessel and have the payout reduced by its salvage value, allowing you to repair it independently if you choose, though this varies by insurer and circumstances.

Getting a Genuine Repair Quote Matters

Since the decision often comes down to comparing repair cost against value, having an accurate, detailed quote from a qualified repairer is an important part of the process. A properly scoped quote that reflects the real cost of doing the repair correctly, not cutting corners, gives your insurer the right information to make a fair assessment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a fixed percentage that determines a write-off for boats or caravans?
Not typically. Unlike some car insurance arrangements, boats and caravans are generally assessed case-by-case based on the specific repair cost versus value comparison.
Can I disagree with my insurer's decision to write off my boat or caravan?
Yes, if you believe the assessment is inaccurate, you can raise it with your insurer, and if unresolved, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) is available to help with disputes.
If it's written off, can I keep it and repair it myself?
In some cases, yes, you may be able to request the salvage and have your payout adjusted accordingly, though this depends on your insurer's policies and the specific circumstances.
Does agreed value or market value cover affect this decision?
Yes, agreed value cover uses the amount set when the policy began, while market value cover uses an assessed value at the time of the claim, which can be more variable.

Let's Discuss Your Repair

If you need fibreglass repairs in Brisbane or South-East Queensland, get in touch with us today. We're happy to discuss your repair and provide advice on the best solution.

WE'LL AIM TO GET BACK TO YOU WITHIN 24 HOURS

Phone

Disclaimer: This information is general guidance only and is not financial, legal or insurance advice. Policy terms, exclusions and claim outcomes vary by insurer and individual circumstances. Always refer to your specific Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), or speak with your insurer or a licensed adviser, for advice relevant to your situation. LBM Fibreglass accepts no liability for any action taken in reliance on this general information.